CLEVELAND — The Knicks keep telling us this season is different. Nights like Tuesday night make you wonder how different it really is.
Because when the game mattered, when the temperature rose just enough to feel like spring basketball, the Knicks didn’t push back against the Cleveland Cavaliers. They folded. And teams with championship dreams aren’t supposed to look this small in March, never mind June.
Final score said 109–94. The game itself felt wider than that.
Donovan Mitchell scored 23 and controlled the rhythm whenever Cleveland needed calm. Jarrett Allen bullied the paint for 19 points and 10 rebounds. Even James Harden — happy to pick his spots — added 20 and helped turn the game in a third quarter that effectively ended New York’s night.
That quarter told the whole story.
The Knicks came out of halftime down only six, 60–54, still very much alive. Then the rims in Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse might as well have shrunk to the size of coffee cups. New York went 3-for-24 from the field. Three makes. Twenty-four tries. The kind of stretch that drains belief from a bench and oxygen from a season narrative.
Cleveland outscored them 23–11 in those twelve minutes, and just like that a competitive game turned into confirmation of an uncomfortable idea: the Knicks are good, but good may be where the story ends.
Jalen Brunson finished with 20 points. Mikal Bridges added 18. Together they shot 12-for-36, chasing shots instead of dictating them. The Knicks as a team shot 35-for-86 and an icy 27 percent from three against a Cavaliers defense that arrived ranked near the bottom of the league defending the arc.
Opportunities were there. The Knicks simply missed them.
Mitchell Robinson fought for everything inside, pulling down 15 rebounds, one shy of his season high. Effort wasn’t absent. Execution was.
And contenders separate themselves exactly there.
Cleveland sensed weakness late in the third, turning a manageable 71–63 lead into a crushing 13–2 run that stretched into the fourth quarter. By the time the Cavaliers pushed the margin to 98–78 midway through the final period, the only suspense left was how quickly the clock would run out.
Both teams now sit at 37–22, tied for third in the Eastern Conference standings. On paper, they look like equals. The Knicks even hold the head-to-head edge if things finish level.
But basketball isn’t played on paper. It’s played in moments like that third quarter, when defenses tighten and shots stop falling and somebody has to impose their will.
Tuesday night, that somebody wasn’t wearing blue and orange.
The Knicks have spent months building the case that this season could lead somewhere special. Depth. Toughness. A star guard who embraces pressure. All true.
Still, championship teams don’t produce the worst shooting quarter they’ve had since 2018 against a direct conference rival in late February. Championship teams don’t disappear offensively when the game tilts.
There are losses, and then there are reminders.
This one felt like a reminder that the climb from playoff team to title team remains steep. The standings say the Knicks belong near the top of the East.
Nights like this suggest the parade route is still a long way from Manhattan.
And if performances like this travel with them into the postseason, the hard truth becomes unavoidable:
There will be no chip.